I personally like the Current Home Page and only because I like to view all the new posts daily. I'm usually on once a day, and if I've been following a thread I like to see the new posts.
Now the Forum main page is good with all the links to the different topics but that doesnt outway the "new post list" in my opinion.
What I would like to see is the Forum Main page with a small section at the top with the most recent posts. I think that would be perfect, now is it possible?
Any ways i vote the current page for now.
Chris